Apple iPhone 5: Ready for Disappointment

Apple will unveil the iPhone 5 September 12. Will it be all current Android phones already are?

September 10, 2012
iPhone 5: Ready for DisappointmentSource: Getty Images

Apple CEO introduces the disappointing (to me) iPhone 4S last October. Will iPhone 5 meet my tech spec expectations?

After being defeated in an epic sword battle, Inigo Montoya begged to know the identity of his black-clad conqueror. Replied the masked and mysterious Man in Black, "Get used to disappointment."

Last October, all expected the iPhone 4S to have a larger screen and 4G LTE connectivity. Instead, it grew in stature and capability as much as any four-year-old turning five.

Dis-a-POIN-ted!

And now, expectations have been similar raised for the iPhone 5, which will be unveiled Wednesday (September 12) and is supposed to be everything the iPhone 4S was supposed to be a year ago.

And knowing what I think I know about what the iPhone 5 will be - well, I'm now used to disappointment.

iPhone 5 spec update

Here's what I know about what the iPhone 5 will be, at least according to most reports:

All well and good, except...

Entry level cutting edge

Last week, Motorola, itself fighting to stay current in the smartphone guy, unwrapped three new Droid RAZRs. After a lot of speechifyin', the company proudly unveiled the Motorola HD and Motorola HD Maxx, each with a 4.7-inch 1280 x 768 pixel screen and with stout batteries able to enable chatting for 16 and 21.5 hours, respectively, packed in packages 8.3mm and 8.9mm thin, respectively.

Maxx HD with 32 GB of memory built-in and a microSD card slot to add more storage space is priced at $199.99; presumably the lesser endowed HD with 16 GB of memory and a card slot to add more will cost less.

And bringing up the rear of the new RAZR line? The baby Droid RAZR M - with a 4.3-inch screen and 20 hours of standby battery life. Thanks to its bezel-to-bezel screen, RAZR M is packed into a tight package just around the same size as iPhone 5 and its theoretic 4.065-inch display.

The new Droids are comparable in specs (other than the super-long battery life) to the Samsung Galaxy III, the HTC One X and many other new phones. Smartphones with 4.5+-inch screens, dual core 1.2+ GHz processors and less than 9mm thin are the new normal.

iPhone 5 will barely reach these tech spec markers.

No, I'm not looking forward to a phone that, compared to its faster-growing Android classmates, will look as if it's been left back a grade.

iPhone advantage?

For Apple these days, pure hardware specs take a back seat to iPhone's real advantage in OS, apps, and both content and software ecosystem.

Android, for instance, lacks a desktop OS parallel, integrated content purchase and management alternatives, security issues, and has suffered continual set-backs in tablet alternatives save for Amazon's Kindle Fire. Microsoft's Windows Phone is starting so far back in the OS race that both Android and iOS has practically lapped it.

But there's half the non-smartphone-owning population yet to conquer (okay, a little less than half and shrinking fast) and neither Google nor Microsoft is going to cede any of these iOS advantages.

Windows Phone 8 advantages

I got to play with Windows Phone 8 a bit at Nokia's Lumia introductory event last week. Microsoft has not been rewarded in sales for creating a wholly reconceived mobile OS gestalt with Windows Phone (not an iOS copycat like Android), and Windows Phone 8 offers some marvelous improvements (although slicing previous Windows Phone 7/7.5 handsets, what few there are, from the Windows Phone 8 upgrade path is really a major slip-up).

For instance, I love that you can now resize Start screen tiles to emphasize or de-emphasize their importance. I love that there are more and more "live" tiles that make your home screen appear as filled with life as Broadway at theater time compared to the lifeless iOS/Android app mall peopled only by bored security guards.

I especially like the Windows Phone 8 camera software lenses. Remove unwanted objects - like someone wandering in front of the scene just as you snap the photo - with Smart Shoot. Bing Vision is not only a code scanner, it's also a scanner/translator that turns a page filled with one of 36 languages into English, nearly instantly. And Cinemagraphic creates animated GIFs, with one part of a photo moving while the rest remains still - the effect doesn't look as creepy as it sounds.

And the Lumias, like the Samsung Galaxy S III and the new Sony Xperia phones, has NFC with tap-to-pair capabilities - touch the phone to a number of pending NFC-enabled Bluetooth devices such as head/earphones and speakers to instantly pair them. And, of course, NFC means virtual wallet capabilities.

Recent reports indicate Apple will skip on NFC in this iPhone go-round. Unfortunate.

Online and/or on line

But along with the rest of the drooling horde, as soon as Apple says "when," I'll queue up on the interwebs to reserve an iPhone 5 then perhaps stand on line to pick it up. I'm trapped. I've bought too much music, movies and apps from iTunes, and my massive music library can't be moved to another smartphone OS.

So, unless every single hardware report about iPhone 5 is ridiculously wrong, Apple is about to proudly announce a phone that might have been cutting edge technologically a year ago.

But since it didn't, and I expect iPhone 5 to be nearly as technically advanced as some now entry-level Android phones - well, I'm used to disappointment.

But, boy, I hope I'm wrong and instead pleasantly surprised.

Will you buy a new iPhone 5?
Share Your Thoughts
Will you buy a new iPhone 5?
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted in your comment.

Your Privacy
Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.
Nancy | Sep 22, 2012
Bring your iPhone to our network and get UNLIMITED EVERYTHING, includes data/phone/text. Keep everything you currently have on your phone. You can use it with the latest software updates no problem! Monthly service is only $49/month! The best part is that our company doesn't waste money on advertising, they invest those hundreds of millions of dollars a year paying you, the consumer to refer people to us. For example: I unlocked my new iPhone with a permanent unlock which I offer for free for those who sign up with me. I referred 3 people and I got paid a fast action bonus of $50 plus I get $20 a month for each trio I refer. I know a ton of friends that want to save $$ on their cell bill, so If you sign up 6 people that would be $190 on the first month and $40 a month paid via visa debit card. Check it out at income cell phone . C. Om start saving now, start earning! Over 250,000 have signed up already! Notice: this is not for skeptical people. This is a great opportunity for those who know how to recognize one.
Joe | Sep 11, 2012
16:9 aspect? Sounds like Apple is slavishly copying Samsung :) "(not an iOS copycat like Android)" Have you used a Galaxy Nexus? Might be time to do some research.
Anonymous | Oct 8, 2012
I did and it sucks. Grainy picture, phone is as slippery as a bar of soap. The cheap plastic feel that feels like a phone from a toy store...
Danny | Sep 11, 2012
Probably not, but I will make the decision once I see the phone and have a chance to play with it. What Apple has going for it is a superior, better integrated OS than Android as well as a better user interface. However the price you pay for that is a very rigidly controlled environment. Regardless of why, the iPhone set the standard for smart phones and all other phones will be measured against it until something better comes along.
Jenny | Sep 11, 2012
My phone has broken features from two years ago. I held out for last year then decided it wasn't worth it, but this year, I have to get a new one. I need a reliable ringer, sound that turns off, an unbroken screen (yes, I can replace the glass - again - but...) and more speed. Since I have the 3G, I'm assuming this will blow my socks off. Plus I like to take pics. However, I wish it were going to be a phenomenal phone and not an okay phone.
Dave | Sep 11, 2012
Probably not. Call me crazy, but I need a PHONE, and would prefer something smaller than the iPhone4 i have now. If the iPhone 5 is bigger as it appears it will be, then maybe I'll look elsewhere.
Mephano | Sep 11, 2012
I like Google's vision to make all the world's information universatlly available and usable. That means no proprietary file formats. Apple likes to make things proprietary. It even renames your music files when you put it on an apple mobile device so that you can't recognize it and put it somewhere else. I learned the hard way from buying an iPod, and once I found where it put the music files, there were just folders with coded, 4-digit filenames that were completely human-unrecognizable. The Apple strategy of creating a captive audience by making it very difficult for their customers to leave, rather than simply making them WANT to stay because of better products and service, is exactly opposite of any company I want to support. No, I will never buy an iPhone unless Apple completely changes its approach and philosophy ... in other words .. when hell freezes over.
Anonymous | Sep 10, 2012
Sheesh. Apple has crested and touchscreens are now a commodity. Get over it and either stay locked in or throw the hammer as in the 1984 ad.
PDXTony | Sep 10, 2012
I'm trapped. I've bought too much music, movies and apps from iTunes, and my massive music library can't be moved to another smartphone OS. My problem is NOT that the iphone isnt a good phone but that they get people to buy into a system of purchasing music, media, and everything else in your life. I have seen multiple tech reviewers shrug and say well my family and I are already setup with Apple at home so its not practical to change... They are just in the grin and bare it mode Dont get my wrong I loved Apple in the 80's but that was then and this is now.. Now that other companies are jumping on the smartphone bandwagon Apple can see the same iceberg that sunk their share of the PC market in the late 80's looming on the horizon. Once Amazon gets the ball rolling on their music app things will shift and in today's market very very quickly. Apple has a LOT riding on this new phone in a consumer perception aspect. If iphone5 is seen as second rate or even equal to the Android models people will ask what happens in the future when Apple hardware updates are glacial? Techies could defend their choice of Apple over any other brand before but the defense is becoming harder and harder... Then the question becomes one of cost and quality A joke that I heard in a phone store by the vendors. When you drop a droid you pick it up and dust if off, when you drop an iphone you pick up the pieces....
Anonymous | Sep 11, 2012
I'm not trapped. Never bought a single song, only one movie and a few apps. But can't one just as easily be trapped in a Google or Microsoft Eco World?
follow us
Subscribe to Newsletters
X
About Life Goes Strong Contributors
Newsletter Sign Up Friends
Newsletter Unsubscribe Contact Us
Mobile App Sitemap